Invasion of the Robot Umpires
A pitch is judged in a fraction of a second: ABS now makes that call instead of the umpire.
配图为棒球比赛场景(Pexels,免费商用),非文中球场。
重点词汇
辅助关闭时只显示词与音标;打开顶部开关后显示中文释义,点正文任意单词可查词并加入生词本。
本练概览
题目
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 3?
In boxes 27–32 on your answer sheet, write YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer, NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer, or NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
When DeJesus first used ABS, he shared decision-making about strikes with it.
解析
A · 第 2 句“Instead of making any judgments himself about a strike, DeJesus had decisions fed to him through an earpiece”
为什么题干说“他和系统共同做决定”,原文是 Instead of making any judgments himself——他根本不做判断,判断由系统给出、他只负责念出来。“共同决策”与“完全不决策”矛盾,因此是 NO。
干扰项看到 shared 容易联想“人机配合”,但 announce the calls 只是照念结果,不等于参与判断。
MLB considered it necessary to amend the size of the strike zone when criticisms were received from players.
解析
D · 第 2 句“players complained about some strange calls. In response, MLB decided to tweak the dimensions of the zone”
为什么球员抱怨 → MLB 决定微调好球区尺寸 → 次年大家认为系统非常稳定。因果链条与题干一一对应。
干扰项tweak 意为“略微调整”,与 amend 同义;本句没有转折,In response 就是信号词。
MLB is keen to justify the money spent on improving the accuracy of ABS's calculations.
解析
D · 第 3 句“MLB says the device is near-perfect, precise to within fractions of an inch.”
为什么原文只强调设备近乎完美、精确到零点几英寸,全文没有提到花费、预算或“为花钱辩护”。
干扰项precise to within fractions of an inch 会让人误以为在“证明钱花得值”,但“强调精度”不等于“解释成本”,属于典型的 NOT GIVEN。
The hundred-mile-an-hour fastball led to a more exciting style of play.
解析
F · 第 6 句“It flattened the game into strikeouts, walks, and home runs—a type of play lacking much action.”
为什么原文说这种快球把比赛压平成三振、保送、本垒打——lacking much action,即“缺少看点”,与“更精彩”正相反。
干扰项fastball 听起来很刺激,凭常识会选 YES;必须以原文的 lacking much action 为准。
The differing proposals for alterations to the baseball bat led to fierce debate on Sword's team.
解析
G · 第 2 句“Any rule that existed, they talked about changing—from changing the bats to changing the geometry of the field.”
为什么原文只说他们讨论过改球棒、改场地,随后这些方案全部被排除,完全没提是否发生过“激烈辩论”。
干扰项from changing the bats to… 证明确实讨论过球棒,但讨论不等于激烈争论,fierce 属于程度上的无中生有。
ABS makes changes to the shape of the strike zone feasible.
解析
G · 第 4 句“you can load any strike zone you want into the system”
为什么Sword 说只要技术做对了,任何形状的好球区都能载入系统,甚至可以是三角形或“德州形状”,即形状可变且可行。
干扰项有人把 blob、shaped like Texas 当成玩笑而否定,但那恰恰是“可行”的例证。
Complete the summary using the list of phrases, A–H, below. Calls by the umpire
Write the correct letter, A–H, in boxes 33–37 on your answer sheet.
Even after ABS was developed, MLB still wanted human umpires to shout out decisions as they had in their .
解析
B · 第 1 句“wanted human umpires to announce the calls, just as they would have done in the past”
为什么as they had in their ______ 对应 just as they would have done in the past:他们要做的仍是过去那些事,即 former roles(过去的职责)。
干扰项E widespread approval 与“喊出判罚”无关;A pitch boundary 是地点概念,不是角色。
The umpire's job had, at one time, required a about whether a ball was a strike.
解析
B · 第 3 句“Previously, calling a strike was a judgment call on the part of the umpire.”
为什么judgment call 就是“靠人判断的决定”,换成名词短语即 subjective assessment(主观评估)。
干扰项A pitch boundary 会让人以为“需要一条界线”,但题干是 required a ______ about whether…,需要的是“判断”。
A ball is considered a strike when the batter does not hit it and it crosses through a extending approximately from the batter's knee to his chest.
解析
B · 第 4 句“an imaginary zone about seventeen inches wide, stretching from the batter's knees to the middle of his chest”
为什么原文明确说这是 an imaginary zone(想象出来的区域),对应 H perceived area——感知中的区域,而非画在场上的界线。
干扰项A pitch boundary 是最强干扰:它确实是“边界”,但原文强调 imaginary,所以不能用 boundary。
In the past, over strike calls were not uncommon, but today everyone accepts the complete ban on pushing or shoving the umpire.
解析
C · 第 1 句“countless arguments between a team's manager and the umpire have taken place over its boundaries”
为什么countless arguments = numerous disputes(无数次争执),与后句“如今推搡裁判被完全禁止”形成今昔对比。
干扰项C team tactics 看似与教练有关,但原文强调的是“争吵”这个行为,不是战术。
One difference, however, is that during the first game DeJesus used ABS, strike calls were met with .
解析
B · 第 5 句“there was no heckling and no shouted disagreement. Nobody said a word.”
为什么no heckling、no shouted disagreement、Nobody said a word,三句都在说“一片安静”,对应 total silence。
干扰项E widespread approval 是“广泛赞同”,但原文只写没人出声,没有升级成赞同。
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
Write the correct letter in boxes 38–40 on your answer sheet.
What does the writer suggest about ABS in the fifth paragraph?
解析
E · 第 7 句“There was a dialogue between pitcher and umpire.”
为什么第五段讲“人至少会吼回去”,投手与裁判之间曾经有“对话”,而机器精准得近乎刻板。作者的意思是:机器取消了这种人味,也就削弱了比赛的一部分魅力。
干扰项A 说“必然判错”,原文反而夸它精准;C 说“裁判会消失”,原文明确 MLB 仍要人宣布结果;D 说“改规则呼声变高”,该段未提。
Morgan Sword says that the introduction of ABS
解析
F · 第 2 句“executives are terrified of losing younger fans, as has been the case with horse racing and boxing”
为什么Sword 说 ABS 属于“让棒球更刺激”的大项目,因为管理层极怕像赛马、拳击那样流失年轻观众——即为了留住年轻受众。
干扰项B 提到“跟上其他运动”,那是第八段讲 VAR 与鹰眼时的内容,不是 Sword 的说法;A、C 文中无据。
Why does the writer include the views of Noë and Russo?
解析
J · 第 2 句“We watch baseball to kill time, not to maximize it.”
为什么Noë 说这是“用算法把生活里难做的选择拿走”,Russo 说“什么都完美就没什么可聊”。两人的共同点是:精准并不等于好看。
干扰项A 说“态度差异很大”,但两人立场一致、都是反对;B 把“完美很怪”误读为“期望不切实际”;D 文中未提。