干净的水是权利,但「免费」未必是答案
公共政策 · 水资源 · Cambridge IELTS 20 · Test 1 Writing Task 2

Access to clean water is a basic human right. Therefore every home should have a water supply that is provided free of charge. Do you agree or disagree?
1 · IntroductionIt is difficult to argue with the first half of this statement: without clean water, no other right can be exercised for long. Whether that right obliges the state to deliver water to every household at no cost is a separate question, and on that point I disagree. A right of access is not the same thing as a product with a price of zero.
2 · Body 1 · 为什么「免费」站不住Water arrives at a tap only after it has been stored, treated, pumped and tested, and every one of those steps costs money. Someone has to replace the pipes, which in older cities leak a third of what they carry. If households pay nothing, the only source of that money is general taxation, and the price signal that discourages waste disappears. Unmetered, free supply tends to produce exactly what one would expect: longer showers, unattended leaks and households that never notice a burst pipe until the street floods. In other words, giving water away can reduce the amount available in a drought, which harms the very people the policy is meant to protect.
3 · Body 2 · 更可行的替代方案This does not mean the poor should be asked to choose between water and food. A better instrument is a lifeline tariff: a basic volume, say twenty-five litres per person per day, supplied free or almost free, with charges rising steeply for consumption above it. South Africa adopted precisely this model after 1994, and it delivers the human right in practice while keeping the utility solvent. Where metering is impractical, a means-tested credit on the bill achieves the same result. The cost then falls on those who can bear it rather than on the network as a whole.
4 · ConclusionI therefore agree that clean water is a right, but not that it must be free to every home regardless of income. Guaranteeing a free minimum, and charging for what lies above it, protects both public health and the infrastructure that makes the guarantee possible.
题目其实包含两个命题:① 干净水是基本人权;② 因此每个家庭都应免费获得。全盘同意或全盘反对都会让论证变浅。这里先接受 ①、否定 ②,并在最后一句点明区别(right of access ≠ zero price),立场从第一段就立住了。注意不要写成 "I partly agree" 这种模糊表态,要具体到「同意哪一半」。
这一段不空谈「水很重要」,而是列出成本链条:储存、处理、泵送、检测、换管。"leak a third of what they carry" 是发达国家管网的真实损耗水平,这种具体数字比任何形容词都有说服力。最后一句把逻辑推到底——免费反而可能在旱季减少可用水量,从而伤害政策本想保护的人,这是把论证推向反直觉的 7 分动作。
只反驳不给替代方案,Task Response 会停在 6。这里给出 lifeline tariff(生命线水价)+ 具体水量(每人每天 25 升)+ 真实案例(南非 1994 年后)。接着补一个 fallback(无法装表时用账单抵扣),显示考虑过现实条件。结尾一句把成本落到「付得起的人身上」,回扣公平。
好的结论不是重复开头,而是把两段的结论压成一句可执行的话:保底免费 + 超额收费。没有引入新论点,也没有喊口号。
| 维度 | 估分 | 说明 |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 7.5 | 两个命题都拆开了,立场一致,方案具体;若能再加一个反方让步(如「免费可减少偷水」)可到 8。 |
| Coherence & Cohesion | 8.0 | 四段各司其职,段内先因后果;连接词克制,靠指代(this does not mean / in other words)推进。 |
| Lexical Resource | 8.0 | lifeline tariff、means-tested、solvent 等术语准确;无生造搭配。 |
| Grammatical Range | 7.5 | 有 cleft 与条件句,但长句比例略高,个别句子可再拆短以增加节奏。 |