少坐飞机:环保收益能不能盖过代价
环境 · 航空与个人选择 · Cambridge IELTS 20 · Test 3 Writing Task 2

Some people have decided to reduce the number of times they fly every year or to stop flying altogether. Do you think the environmental benefits of this development outweigh the disadvantages for individuals and businesses?
1 · IntroductionA reluctance to fly, strong enough in Sweden to acquire its own word, has moved from a personal quirk to a visible social trend. I believe its environmental benefits do outweigh the disadvantages, but only because the people giving up flights are, in the main, those who fly most often.
2 · Body 1 · 环境收益Aviation is responsible for roughly two to three per cent of global carbon dioxide emissions, and when the warming effect of contrails and nitrogen oxides is included, its contribution to climate change is larger than that figure suggests. It is also one of the few emission sources that is difficult to decarbonise: electric aircraft remain limited to short hops, and sustainable fuel is scarce and expensive. A single return flight from London to New York can produce more emissions than a year of driving, so a decision to forgo two or three long-haul trips is not a gesture. In Sweden, domestic passenger numbers fell by around nine per cent in the year the movement peaked, and night trains to continental Europe were reinstated partly in response.
3 · Body 2 · 代价确实存在The disadvantages are nonetheless real and unevenly shared. Businesses that depend on face-to-face negotiation, from engineering to fashion, lose something that videoconferencing reproduces poorly, and a small exporter may lose contracts to a competitor willing to board a plane. Tourism-dependent economies, especially island states, are hit hardest: their emissions are negligible, yet their incomes depend on other people's flights. Individuals pay in other currencies too, since immigrants who stop flying see their families rarely, and students miss opportunities that only travel provides. There is also a leakage problem: an empty seat is quickly filled by another passenger, so unless demand falls sharply, the aircraft still takes off.
4 · ConclusionOn balance the benefits are genuine, because the cuts fall disproportionately on the small group responsible for most emissions, and because they create political pressure for rail investment and cleaner fuel. Yet the practice remains symbolic unless it is supported by policy; if governments price aviation properly and fund alternatives, the trade-off can be made worth it for everyone.
"strong enough in Sweden to acquire its own word" 指的是 flygskam(飞行羞耻),一句话把话题从抽象变具体,也暗示这个现象有真实的社会基础。最后一句给出有条件的立场:收益大于代价,但前提是「谁在减少飞行」。把结论写成有条件判断,比无条件的 outweigh 更经得起推敲。
先给 2–3% 的占比(常被拿来淡化航空责任),紧接着指出加上尾迹与氮氧化物后影响更大——这是主动处理对手论据的写法。再补「难以脱碳」的结构性理由(电动飞机只能短途、可持续燃料稀缺),最后用伦敦—纽约往返=一年开车的量级,以及瑞典国内客流下降约 9%、夜火车复运的具体例子收尾。三个层次:全球占比 → 技术刚性 → 个体量级。
企业(面对面谈判)、岛国旅游业(排放极小却靠别人坐飞机)、移民家庭、学生——四类主体各有各的损失,这样才叫讨论 disadvantages for individuals and businesses(题目原话)。最后补 carbon leakage:座位会被别人买走,飞机照飞。这一句让论证不偏向任何一方,也是 7.5 的关键。
承认收益真实,同时指出它可能只是 symbol——只有配价格政策与替代供给才成立。这样既回答了 outweigh,又没有滑进「大家都别坐飞机」的口号。
| 维度 | 估分 | 说明 |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 7.5 | 两边都扎实,且给出有条件结论;若补一个「短途可替代、长途难替代」的分层会更锋利。 |
| Coherence & Cohesion | 8.0 | 四段呈「立场—收益—代价—条件结论」,段内分层清楚;指代明确。 |
| Lexical Resource | 8.0 | aviation / decarbonise / leakage / long-haul 等术语使用准确,搭配自然。 |
| Grammatical Range | 7.5 | 复杂句使用得当,个别句子偏长;条件句与让步句多样。 |